First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
print this   Print

Professors decry decision to ban books in Puerto Rico high schools

By The Associated Press
09.15.09

SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico — Several university professors in Puerto Rico are protesting a decision to ban five books from the curriculum at public high schools in the U.S. territory because of coarse language.

The Spanish-language books previously were read as part of the 11th-grade curriculum, but proofreaders this year alerted education officials about “coarse” slang, including references to genitalia in Mejor te lo cuento: antologia personal, by Juan Antonio Ramos.

Also among the banned books is the novel Aura by Carlos Fuentes of Mexico, one of Latin America’s most prominent contemporary writers. The other four authors whose works are affected are from Puerto Rico.

Magali Garcia Ramis, a communications professor at the University of Puerto Rico, expressed concern on Sept. 12 about how books are being evaluated by the island’s Department of Education.

“This kind of mentality rejects everything that is art and only associates sexuality with inappropriateness,” Garcia Ramis said.

Department of Education spokesman Alan Obrador could not be reached, and the Puerto Rico Teachers Association also was unavailable for this story.

The island’s secretary of state, Kenneth McClintock, showed his support for screening books when he updated his Facebook status on Sept. 12. He said he was “glad” that Puerto Rico’s Secretary of Education Carlos C. “Chardon is taking a hard look at the rough vocabulary in some assigned-reading books!”

Silvia Alvarez Curbelo, another communications professor at the University of Puerto Rico, said so-called bad words have to be considered in their context.

She and other professors said the ban was reminiscent of censorship imposed by the Taliban, the extremist Islamic movement whose regime in Afghanistan banned music, movies, TV and nearly all other forms of entertainment as part of their strict interpretation of Islamic laws.

“These kind of things happened in Afghanistan under the Taliban,” she said of the book ban.

Fuentes’ Aura includes a brief romantic encounter beneath a crucifix. It is a scene that prompted Mexico's former interior secretary to try to have the book dropped from a reading list at his daughter’s private school, without success.

Fuentes said last year that the attempt boosted sales of the book.

The other banned books are Antologia personal, by Jose Luis Gonzalez; El entierro de Cortijo, by Edgardo Rodriguez Julia; and Reunion de espejos, a compilation of essays by Jose Luis Vega.


Related

Censor READ this book

By Courtney Holliday 27th annual Banned Books Week — advertised as the only national celebration of freedom to read — starts tomorrow. 09.26.08

11th Circuit: Miami school board can pull Cuba book from libraries

Panel is split on whether book was banned or removed; dissenting judge says it appears book was yanked for political rather than educational reasons. 02.06.09

Banned Books Week celebrates fight for intellectual freedom
By Allie Diffendal And Tango Makes Three again tops American Library Association's annual list of most-challenged books. 09.26.09

Supreme Court stays out of Miami book-banning dispute
High court lets stand ruling by 11th Circuit, which found that school district wouldn't be infringing on free speech because book presents inaccurate view of life in Cuba. 11.16.09

1st Circuit: Witnesses can proselytize behind Puerto Rico's gates
Unlike in the U.S., where streets inside gated communities are private, such streets are considered public thoroughfares in U.S. territory. 02.10.11

Banned books

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.



Last system update: Thursday, June 20, 2013 | 00:25:15
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
Columnists
Experts
First Amendment publications
1 for All
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings®
Events
Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links